A lead tech told me my solder joints looked 'cold and scared' and it actually fixed my work
Six months ago a lead tech at our hangar in Bakersfield watched me reflow a connector on a King radio and said my joints were 'cold and scared.' Meaning I was pulling the iron away too fast and not letting the pad heat up. He made me sit there and redo the same 9 pins three times with a timer until I got the feel for it. My rework rejection rate on solder work has dropped from about 1 in 5 to almost nothing since then. What's the harshest feedback you got that actually made you better at the bench?
Did he make you hold the iron on there longer or was it more about how you fed the solder in? I had a guy tell me my wire splices looked like I was "afraid of the heat" and that one stuck with me for years. He sat me down and made me practice on scrap wire for a whole afternoon, just watching how the solder flowed when the joint was actually hot enough. Turns out I was rushing because I didn't want to cook the insulation, so I was making ugly blobs instead of smooth shiny joints. Once I learned to trust the heat and move at the right speed my rework rate dropped a lot too.