I finally found my old Angelfire page on the Wayback Machine and spent 3 hours just reading my old guestbook
Typed in an old URL last Tuesday night and there it was. All the frames, the spinning email icon, the hit counter stuck at 4,772. Reading the guestbook entries from 1998 was wild. Some guy named Dave from Ohio signed it just to say "nice page, check out mine" and I have no idea who he is. What's the weirdest guestbook entry you've ever found on an old archive of your own site?